|
The
Genoa Township Board
Work Session
May 16, 2005
6:00 p.m.
AGENDA
Presentation by Neil Lehto concerning the Metro Extension Permits,
Comcast Cable and PanHandle Eastern.
Regular Meeting
May 16, 2005
6:30 p.m.
AGENDA
Approval of Consent Agenda:
1. Payment of Bills.
2. Approval of Minutes: May 2, 2005.
Approval of Regular Agenda:
3. Public Hearing on the Hidden Ponds sewer project for 2005.
A. Call to the property owners and the public.
B. Request for approval of Resolution No. 5 (Confirming Special
Assessment Roll).
C. Request for approval of Resolution No. 6 (Authorizing Payment Out Of
Sewer Fund and directing deposit of the special assessments into the
sewer fund).
D. Request for approval of Resolution No. 7 (Consenting to County Drain
Commissioner Relinquishment of hidden Ponds Drain and assuming
jurisdiction and control by Genoa Township).
4. Consideration of the initiation of a lawsuit against Home Depot
for violation of the August 21, 2002 Circuit Court Agreement, as
requested Ordinance Enforcement Officer Adam VanTassell.
5. Request for approval of the impact assessment (02/23/05),
corresponding to site plan (03/18/05) to construct a 15,654 sq. ft.
office and warehouse building for Trends and Tile, located in Sec. 14 on
the south side of Grand River Avenue between Dorr and Kellogg Road,
petitioned by Lindhout Associates Architects as discussed by the
Planning Commission 03/14/05.
(Please pull related materials from your previous board packet).
6. Request for approval of the impact assessment (04/06/05),
corresponding to a sketch plan to install paving at 7281 W. Grand River,
petitioned by St. Joseph Mercy Health and reviewed by the
Planning Commission 04/25/05.
7. Request for approval of the impact assessment (04/06/05), final
PUD plan (04/06/05) and final PUD agreement (04/06/05) to construct a
14,490 sq. ft. retail store located at 2321 E. Grand River, petitioned
by Walgreens, as discussed by the
Planning Commission 04/25/05.
A. Disposition of PUD Agreement.
B. Disposition of Final PUD Plan.
C. Disposition of Impact Assessment.
8. Request for approval of the impact assessment (05/09/05),
corresponding to site plan to construct a 30,000 sq. ft. private
elementary school and daycare located in Sec. 23 at the northeast corner
of Bauer Road and Challis Road, petitioned by Brighton Country Day
Schoolhouse Facilities, LLC, as discussed by the
Planning Commission 04/25/05.
9. Request for approval of a rezoning application and environmental
impact assessment (09/22/04)for 120 acres located in section 17,
(11-17-400-013,014,015 and 11-17-200-002,006) on the west side of Nixon
Road, just north of Crooked Lake Road, petitioned by FTAG Investments.
The request is to rezone property from AG (Agricultural) and CE (Country
Estates) to MDR (Medium Density Residential), as discussed by the
Planning Commission 10/12/04.
A. Disposition of rezoning request.
B. Disposition of impact assessment
10. Request for approval of an amendment to the General Fund Budget
for fiscal 2004/05 and discussion of the preliminary budget for fiscal
2005/06.
A. Disposition of amendment for fiscal 2004/05.
B. Discussion of changes to the budget for fiscal 2005/06.
11. Request to consider financing options and water rate changes for
the Oak Pointe water system.
Work Session
MINUTES
Mr. Neil Lehto addressed the board concerning the Metro Extension
Permits, Comcast Cable and PanHandle Eastern. He suggested issuing a
pipeline permit for PanHandle Eastern that would include a GIS map of
the pipeline, contact information and insurance. The SBC permit will
expire in 2008 and they need to supply the township with GIS quality
maps telling us where the underground wires are located. A
telecommunications act is being written in the state legislature today
that would encourage competition. With regard to Comcast cable a new
contract asking for a senior citizen discount could be included in the
contract when it comes due in about 12 years. The township can ask for
discretionary items, but we cannot deny their request for renewal.
Regular Meeting
MINUTES
Supervisor McCririe call the regular meeting of the Genoa Township
Board to order at 6:40 p.m. The Pledge of Allegiance was then said. The
following board members were present constituting a quorum for the
transaction of business: Gary McCririe, Paulette Skolarus, Robin Hunt,
Jean Ledford, Todd Smith, Jim Mortensen and Steve Wildman. In addition
there were Township Manager Michael Archinal, Township Attorney Rick
Heikkinen and approximately 30 persons in the audience.
A call to the public was made with no response.
Approval of Consent Agenda:
Moved by Smith, supported by Ledford, to approve all items listed on
the Consent Agenda as submitted. The motion carried unanimously.
1. Payment of Bills.
2. Approval of Minutes: May 2, 2005.
Approval of Regular Agenda:
Moved by Ledford, supported by Smith, to approve the review of the
Regular Agenda with individual action of the board on each item as
requested. The motion carried unanimously.
3. Public Hearing on the Hidden Ponds sewer project for 2005.
Archinal advised the board and audience that the cost of the project
is expected to be $366,000.00. The township will provide funding for the
35 homes with an interest rate of 2% for 20 years. The township does not
require the assessment to be paid off at the sale of the property and
the loan can be assumed, but the township will not subordinate.
A. Call to property owners and the public.
A call to property owners and the public was made with one resident
asking if all the easements had been obtained. McCririe – We are seeking
the needed easements but will go forward with condemning the property if
they cannot be obtained.
B. Request for approval of Resolution No. 5 (Confirming Special
Assessment Roll).
Moved by Mortensen, supported by Hunt, to approve Resolution No. 5,
correcting the number of installments to 20 at 2% per annum. The motion
carried by roll call vote as follows: Ayes – Ledford, Smith, Hunt,
Wildman, Mortensen, Skolarus and McCririe. Nays – None. Absent – None.
C. Request for approval of Resolution No. 6 (Authorizing Payment Out
Of Sewer Fund and directing deposit of the special assessments into the
sewer fund).
Moved by Skolarus, supported by Wildman, to approve Resolution No. 6 as
submitted. The motion carried by roll call vote as follows: Ayes –
Ledford, Smith, Hunt, Wildman, Mortensen, Skolarus and McCririe. Nays –
None. Absent – None.
D. Request for approval of Resolution No. 7 (Consenting to County
Drain Commissioner Relinquishment of Hidden Ponds Drain and assuming
jurisdiction and control by Genoa Township).
Moved by Hunt, supported by Mortensen, to approve Resolution No. 7 as
submitted. The motion carried by roll call vote as follows: Ayes –
Ledford, Smith, Hunt, Wildman, Mortensen, Skolarus and McCririe. Nays –
None. Absent – None.
4. Consideration of the initiation of a lawsuit against Home Depot
for violation of the August 21, 2002 Circuit Court Agreement, as
requested Ordinance Enforcement Officer Adam VanTassell.
VanTassell advised the board that the August 2002 agreement with Home
Depot specifically dealt with violations for outdoor storage that
occurred more than three times in three calendar years.
Moved by Mortensen, supported by Wildman, to have the Heikkinen,
McCririe and Archinal review the violations with Home Depot council and
their home office with possible revocation of the Special Use Permit and
a significant fine for future violations. The motion carried
unanimously.
5. Request for approval of the impact assessment (02/23/05),
corresponding to site plan (03/18/05) to construct a 15,654 sq. ft.
office and warehouse building for Trends and Tile, located in Sec. 14 on
the south side of Grand River Avenue between Dorr and Kellogg Road,
petitioned by Lindhout Associates Architects as discussed by the
Planning Commission 03/14/05.
Moved by Smith, supported by Skolarus, to approve the impact assessment
for Trends and Tile contingent upon the following: Page 2 references an
attachment, and that attachment shall be included. The hours and days of
operation shall be added. The motion carried unanimously.
6. Request for approval of the impact assessment (04/06/05),
corresponding to a sketch plan to install paving at 7281 W. Grand River,
petitioned by St. Joseph Mercy Health and reviewed by the
Planning Commission 04/25/05.
Mortensen asked to be excused from discussion since he sits on the
Board of Trustees at the Health Center. Moved by Smith, supported by
Skolarus, to excuse Mortensen as requested. The motion carried
unanimously.
Moved by Ledford, supported by Hunt, to approve the impact assessment
with the following conditions: The light poles and fixtures will match
the existing ones. Item 9 of the Township Engineer’s letter dated April
14, 2005 will be complied with. The motion carried with Mortensen
abstaining.
7. Request for approval of the impact assessment (04/06/05), final
PUD plan (04/06/05) and final PUD agreement (04/06/05) to construct a
14,490 sq. ft. retail store located at 2321 E. Grand River, petitioned
by Walgreens, as discussed by the
Planning Commission 04/25/05.
A. Disposition of PUD Agreement.
Moved by Ledford, supported by Skolarus, to approve the PUD Agreement
with the following conditions:
1. The Township Attorney shall review the PUD agreement.
2. Cross access agreements will be obtained and recorded with the
property owner to the east prior to the granting of a land use permit.
3. The petitioner will provide the Township with evidence that he has
the right to access Maplecrest Drive and further agrees that Walgreens
and its suppliers will not use Maplecrest Drive for through traffic.
4. Outdoor storage or sales is strictly prohibited.
The motion carried unanimously.
B. Disposition of Final PUD Plan.
Moved by Skolarus, supported by Ledford, to approve the PUD Plan
contingent upon the following:
1. A Land Use Permit will not be issued until an executed Cross
Easement Agreement is provided to the Township.
2. Cross access easements will be obtained and recorded with the
property to the east prior to the granting of a land use permit.
3. The petitioner will provide the Township with evidence that he has
the right to access Maplecrest Drive and further agrees that Walgreens
and its suppliers will not use Maplecrest for through traffic.
4. The petitioner will resurface Maplecrest Drive west from the site
entrance to Golf Club Road with approval from the private road owner(s).
5. No window signs are permitted.
6. All greenbelts will be irrigated.
7. The petitioner will arrange with the trash hauling company to pick up
trash prior to the opening hours of the pharmacy.
8. Items 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 of the Township Engineer’s letter dated
April 20, 2005 will be complied with.
9. The memo dated May 6, 2005 from Svetlana Vrubel will become an
attachment to the final PUD Plan.
The motion carried unanimously.
C. Disposition of Impact Assessment.
Moved by Ledford, supported by Smith, to approve the impact assessment
adding the following: Hours of operation will be 24 and there will be no
outdoor storage or sales on the site. The motion carried unanimously.
8. Request for approval of the impact assessment (05/09/05),
corresponding to site plan to construct a 30,000 sq. ft. private
elementary school and daycare located in Sec. 23 at the northeast corner
of Bauer Road and Challis Road, petitioned by Brighton Country Day
Schoolhouse Facilities, LLC, as discussed by the
Planning Commission 04/25/05.
Moved by Skolarus, supported by Ledford, to approve the impact
assessment with the following conditions:
1. The petitioner will add additional brick to the southwest wall of the
building with the total brick to be approximately 42% and the total EFIS
to be 30% and will change the labels to reflect the additional brick.
2. The petitioner will have all entrance and exit points approved by the
Livingston County Road Commission and Township Engineer and will attempt
to develop a secondary emergency exit. While we don’t require a new
four-way intersection be constructed at the site entrance, we feel it
would be a much safer access point until the improvements are made to
the new Challis Road configuration.
3. The Planning Commission will allow the existing landscaping on the
south property line to serve as the buffer and no additional landscaping
is required.
4. The Petitioner will modify the existing light cut sheets to fully
shield the lens.
5. The Planning Commission will allow a 1:3 slope in the vicinity east
of the access drive and south of the school.
6. The Petitioner will file for application to have a flashing caution
signal on Bauer Road that will help reduce traffic speeds.
7. Fire Marshall approval of the plan is required.
8. All rooftop equipment shall be shielded.
9. Parking, as displayed on the site, is adequate.
10.Most important, this approval is conditioned upon the Livingston
County Road Commission and the petitioner reaching a written agreement
concerning the road right-of-way and the relocation of the road before
June 15, 2005.
The motion carried as follows: Ayes – Ledford, Smith, Wildman,
Mortensen, Skolarus and McCririe. Nay – Hunt, Absent – None.
9. Request for approval of a rezoning application and environmental
impact assessment (09/22/04) for 120 acres located in section 17,
(11-17-400-013,014,015 and 11-17-200-002,006) on the west side of Nixon
Road, just north of Crooked Lake Road, petitioned by FTAG Investments.
The request is to rezone property from AG (Agricultural) and CE (Country
Estates) to MDR (Medium Density Residential), as discussed by the
Planning Commission 10/12/04.
The petitioner reiterated his presentation to the Planning Commission
of 10/12/04. McCririe – The Genoa Township Planning Commission
recommended denial of this request. The Livingston County Planning
Commission recommended denial of this request. Reference is made to the
Minutes of the Township Planning Commission where reasons for denial
were given. The petitioner provided no new information this evening that
would compel disagreement with the Township or County Planning
Commissions. This petition does not meet the conditions of the Township
Zoning Ordinance citing Section 22.04.
A. Disposition of rezoning request.
Moved by Skolarus, supported by Ledford, to deny the request for
rezoning as submitted referencing the comments and reasons for denial as
included in the Minutes of the Planning Commission and citing Section
22.04 of the Township Zoning Ordinance. The motion carried unanimously.
B. Disposition of impact assessment.
Moved by Ledford, supported by Skolarus, to deny approval of the impact
assessment for the same reasons. The motion carried unanimously.
10. Request for approval of an amendment to the General Fund Budget
for fiscal 2004/05 and discussion of the preliminary budget for fiscal
2005/06.
A. Disposition of amendment for fiscal 2004/05.
Moved by Ledford, supported by Mortensen, to approve the amendments for
this fiscal years General Fund budget as requested. The motion carried
unanimously.
B. Discussion of changes to the budget for fiscal 2005/06.
It was the consensus of the board that salaries for elected officials
should stand. Further, that the township trustees would receive a $25.00
increase for meeting fees, with the Zoning Board of Appeals and Planning
Commission receiving a $15.00 increase. This action will be formally
adopted at the Public Hearing of the General Fund budget scheduled for
June 20, 2005.
11. Request to consider financing options and water rate changes for
the Oak Pointe water system.
Moved by Ledford, supported by Wildman, to adopt the rates and
changes as recommended in the April 23, 2005 letter from Certified
Public Accountants PHP for the Oak Pointe Water and Sewer District as
follows:
Oak Pointe Water – Increase from $1.64 to $2.12 per 1,000 gallons.
Oak Pointe Sewer – Increase from $4.18 to $4.24 per 1,000 gallons.
Oak Pointe Sewer (Flat Rate) – Increase from $79.00 per quarter to
$81.37.
The motion carried unanimously.
The regular meeting of the Genoa Township Board was adjourned at 9:15
p.m.
Paulette A. Skolarus
Genoa Township Clerk
(Press/Argus 05/25/05)
|